Data Mining Book Review: Dance with Chance

November 3, 2012 by Sandro Saitta
Filed under: Uncategorized 

If you're new here, you may want to subscribe to my RSS feed. Thanks for visiting!

danceIf you ever worked on time series prediction (forecasting), you should read Dance with Chance. It is written by  a statistician, a psychologist and a decision scientist (Makriddakis, Hogarth and Gaba). As it is the case in The Numerati or Super Crunchers, authors explain complex notions to a non-expert audience. I find the book really interesting and provocative.

The main concept of Dance with Chance is the “illusion of control”. It is when you think you control a future event or situation, that is in fact mainly due to chance. This is the opposite of fatalism (when you think you have no control, although you have). The book teaches how to avoid being fooled by this illusion of control. This is a very interesting reading for any data miner, particularly involved with forecasting. The books contains dozens of examples of the limitation of forecasting techniques. For example, it explains the issues of forecasting the stock market and when predictions are due to chance. Authors use a brilliant mix of statistics and psychology to prove their point.

Of course, it is difficult for someone in the field to completely agree with the authors. For example, they often state that no one can predict the future in advance. Formulated this way, one may agree. However, data mining and machine learning techniques are able to predict future situations (based on past data) to a certain extent (probabilities). Another bias of the authors is their tendency to reject complex models simply because…they are complex. Although I know the famous Occam’s razor, advanced and complex techniques such as Support Vector Machine (SVM) have proven their efficiency in several applications. To conclude, whether you agree or not with the authors, Dance with Chance open your eyes on the illusion of control and thus on the limitations of predictive algorithms.

Dance with Chance: Making Luck Work for You

No TweetBacks yet. (Be the first to Tweet this post)
  • Share/Bookmark

Comments

2 Comments on Data Mining Book Review: Dance with Chance

  1. Marcel Baumgartner on Tue, 6th Nov 2012 11:41 am
  2. Hello Sandro,

    great that you review this book here. I have very good memories reading it during my summer vacation on the Ile de Ré on the Atlantic Coast of France. I was looking at the waves and tides, and tides are predictable. The subway uncertainty (or Mediocristan, Taleb’s name) vs. the Coconut uncertanity (Extremistan). The best is shown at the end: the 6 truths of forecasting:

    1. The future is never exactly like the past.
    2. “Complex” statistical models fit past data well but don’t necessarily predict the future.
    3. “Simple” models don’t necessarily fit past data well but predict the future better than complex models.
    4. Both statistical models and people have been unable to capture the full extent of future uncertainty and been surprised by large forecasting errors and events they did not consider.
    5. Expert judgment is typically inferior to simple statistical models.
    6. Averaging (whether of models or expert opinions) usually improves forecasting accuracy.

    Now you need to read “Signal to Noise” by Nate Silver !

    Marcel

  3. Sandro Saitta on Thu, 29th Nov 2012 2:42 pm
  4. Thanks for your comment Marcel. I have juste read “Future Ready” by Morlidge and Player (one of your suggestions)…very nice!

Tell me what you're thinking...





  • Swiss Association for Analytics

  • T-shirts, Mugs & Mousepads


    All benefits given to a charity association
  • Data Mining Search Engine

    Supported by AnalyticBridge

  • Archives

  • Reading Recommandations